Footnotes to Plato from the foothills of the Superstition Mountains

Tribal America

One of my darker thoughts is that in the end tribal allegiances trump whatever people piously imagine unites us. For a time the great American experiment worked.  People assimilated under the aegis of e pluribus unum.  People valued liberty over material equality.  But now talk of these ideals seems quaint to a growing number.  Books like Dennis Prager's latest that celebrate them may have come too late.  We may have passed the tipping point toward the descent into tribalism.  We shall see.
 
Blut und Boden shouldn't matter but it does to leftists.  Here is an excerpt from my The Hyphenated American (link below):
 

The liberal-left emphasis on blood and ethnicity and origins and social class is dangerous and divisive.  Suppose you come from Croatia.  Is that something to be proud of?  You had to be born somewhere of some set of parents.  It wasn't your doing.  It is an element of your facticity.  Be proud of the accomplishments  that individuate you, that make you an individual, as opposed to a member of a tribe.  Celebrate your freedom, not your facticity.

If you must celebrate diversity, celebrate a diversity of ideas and a diversity of individuals, not a diversity of races and ethnicities and groups. Celebrate individual thinking, not 'group-think.'    The Left in its perversity has it backwards.  They emphasize the wrong sort of diversity while ignoring the right kind.  They go to crazy lengths to promote the wrong kind while squelching diversity of thought and expression with their speech codes and political correctness.

 


Posted

in

,

by

Tags: