Footnotes to Plato from the foothills of the Superstition Mountains

State Power and the Conscience of the Individual

Why shouldn't the state have and exercise the power to override the conscience of the individual?  Suppose I am in the bumper sticker and T-shirt business.  You come to my shop and order a thousand Fuck Obama! bumper stickers and a thousand Hillary Sucks! T-shirts.  I explain to you that to do as you request would be to violate my longstanding commitment to civility  and that you should take your business elsewhere.

Question: Should the power of the state be used to force me to serve this particular customer?  If not, why not?  Am I not discriminating against him on the basis of his creed, which includes a commitment to the absolute right of free speech?  Am I not interfering with his exercise of this absolute right?

"Fuck Obama" Bumper Sticker


by

Tags: