A brilliant article by John Zmirak. Here is the theological meat of it. Zmirak makes a point I either made or was about to make.
Let’s look more carefully at the language of the Lord’s Prayer. It tells us to ask God only for the sort of forgiveness we are willing to offer our fellow sinners on earth. The model of our conduct is God’s mercy and justice rather than man’s. So far so good. Does God forgive those who are utterly impenitent? No, He doesn’t. That’s too much to expect from Him. So it seems unreasonable to read Jesus’s words as if He expects from us what He will not do Himself. No doubt we should let go of bitterness and the hunger for vengeance, for our own spiritual health. We should pray for our enemies’ repentance and final redemption. But to blithely write off the crimes of those who wielded power wickedly, harming millions of our fellow citizens, while they still preen and tyrannize, seems less holy than reckless—even irresponsible.
