2 thoughts on “Soul as Homunculus: On Homuncular Explanation”

  1. Bill, you are back with the Transcendental Ego! I am happy to see that. Another interesting post on a fascinating subject. I am now working my way through Husserl’s *Ideas* — my second swing at it since college — so this post comes at a nice time for me.

    I was struck most by your no-thing ‘fourth approach’, along with your penultimate sentence: “Consciousness is real, but cannot be reified: it is other than every *res*, every being; but it is not nothing either!”

    It’s no doubt perilous to use God in an analogy, but God exists and He is not a being-among-beings. God is ‘no-thing’ (in the sense of not being an *ens*, a *res*), but He exists nonetheless. (Of course, He exists as Being Itself, but I’m trying not to make that central to this analogy. He exists, but not as a ‘thing’, not as a *res* – I do not mean to take it any further than that.)

    Again, I toss this ‘God analogy’ out with no great confidence, but I have thought of it from time to time. I wonder if you see any plausibility in this as a parallel.

    1. Hi Tom,

      Thanks for stopping by. Yes, I am again circling around the Transcendental Ego, but this time in connection with a deep dive into AI. I am convinced that these astonishing contraptions are wholly meaning-free and are nothing but manipulators of uninterpreted (intrinsically meaningless) symbols. Their seductive (and very dangerous) ‘magic’ works by NEXT-TOKEN-PREDICTION which I am trying to get a handle on. Dangerously seductive because gullible people can be fooled into thinking that they can trust, and enter into, a Buberian I-Thou relation with these pseudo-persons. Imagine an alienated teenage girl who is ‘advised’ by one of these inanimate, insentient, uncaring bots to commit suicide. Imagination aside, this has happened.

      Ultimately, all meaning comes from us. That’s my line. John Searle would agree. But for him, meaning comes from human brains. I can’t go along with this ‘Searle-y’ materialism. For me, there has to be some ultimate source of meaning ‘behind’ human brains. Enter the TE of Husserl and his assistant Eugen Fink. Ultimately, all meaning is ‘constituted’ by and in transcendental subjectivity. But then well-know problems re: idealism and intersubjectivity jump out at us. To touch briefly on the idealism question — to which Roman Ingarden devoted his entire career — meaning, SINN, is in the end for Husserl SEINSINN. This leads to trouble as Ingarden forcefully argues. As for intersubjectivity, how is the ‘constitution’ (terminus technicus) of the other mind AS OTHER possible from the Cartesian starting point? Constitution is an intentional (broad sesne) ‘performance,’ *eine intentionale Leistung.*

      If you have questions about specific passages in IDEAS, I’ll try to answer them.

      Husserl fights shy of reifying transcendental egos. They are not, for him, immaterial, transcenDENT, spiritual substances as they are for Jacques Maritain and other Thomists. I am inclined to that Thomist-personalist view except that it bangs into the Grand Central Conundrum, one formulation of which caught your eye: “Consciousness is real, but cannot be reified: it is other than every *res*, every being; but it is not nothing either!”

      Finally, I am finally ploughing through Polanyi’s PERSONAL KOWLEDGE which has languished on my shelf since I first acquired it in the Fall of 1972 for the princely sum of $2.95. This is a fabulously rich and thoughtful book by a polymath. You should read it. He can be enlisted in support of my animadversions against AI. Briefly, he rejects the idea that there could be a semantic engine/machine.

      His view is neither materialist nor classically theist, but emergentist along the line of Lloyd Morgan and Samuel Alexander. More on Polanyi later.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *