Footnotes to Plato from the foothills of the Superstition Mountains

Hume: Occasionalism Without God?

I wonder if I can get any of my esteemed readers to swallow the following suggestion. Ten years or so ago it came into my head that Hume's analysis of causation in terms of (i) temporal precedence, (ii) spatiotemporal contiguity, and (iii) constant conjunction can be reasonably viewed as occasionalism without God.

For what is the essence of occasionalism if not the view that no natural or 'secondary' cause is a true cause, and that there is only one true cause, namely, God the 'primary' cause? Although occasionalism is often discussed as an ad hoc solution to the problem of mind-body interaction 'occasioned' by Cartesian dualism, occasionalism is a general theory of causation, and there was occasionalism long before Descartes. The doctrine can be traced back at least to al-Ghazali. Here is a good little article by William Hasker that fills in some of the details.


Posted

in

, ,

by

Tags: