Footnotes to Plato from the foothills of the Superstition Mountains

Negative Events: Likelihood versus Gravity of Occurrence

Suppose you pack heat. Someone might ask you, "But what is the likelihood that you, given your cautious and circumspect style of life, will ever be in a situation in which you will need to defend your life, or a family member's life, with deadly force?"

The question is legitimate. The answer is as follows. You must weigh the likelihood of the negative event against the gravity of its occurrence.  Although it may be unlikely that you will need to defend yourself or another with a firearm, the consequences of not being able to do so are dire indeed: death of self or other.

The point is that you must not consider merely the likelihood of negative events, but also their gravity should they occur, when determining courses of action.

For a second example, consider wearing a seat belt. I never drive without seat belt fastened. Given my cautious driving habits, the likelihood of  a serious accident on any given day are very low.  But the consequences of going through the windshield are grave, in two senses of that term.


by

Tags:

Comments

2 responses to “Negative Events: Likelihood versus Gravity of Occurrence”

  1. Joel Farmer Avatar
    Joel Farmer

    Excellent, Mister Bill.

  2. James Soriano Avatar
    James Soriano

    Risk of loss, risk of ruin.
    You are right to consider the probability of a negative outcome against the gravity of its occurrence.
    A “loss” is a state from which damage is recoverable; “ruin” is a state of loss from which there is no recovery.
    A loss takes place when the stack of chips in front of you at Las Vegas goes down. Ruin is the state of having no chips in front of you and you must leave the game.
    Somebody who’s good at considering “the likelihood of negative events” and “their gravity” can make a killing on Wall Street by aligning his bets to profit from negativity.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *