Footnotes to Plato from the foothills of the Superstition Mountains

Category: Uncategorized

  • The President of Harvard and ‘Her Truth’

    Was she hired because of  the 'intersectionality' of her race, sex,  and surname? Story here. Harvard University President Claudine Gay has apologized for her widely condemned Congressional testimony on campus antisemitism, which she said "failed to convey what is my truth." Her truth?  My ass!  There is no such thing as her truth, my truth or yours or…

  • Saturday Night at the Oldies I: The Seder Scene in “Crimes and Misdemeanors”

    "Crimes and Misdemeanors" is Woody Allen's masterpiece. Here is the Seder scene.  The scene ends with Saul saying "If necessary, I will always choose God over the truth."  It works cinematically, but it is a philosophically lame response to the atheist Aunt May. It is lame because Saul portrays the theist as one who self-deceivingly…

  • Secular Self-Deception about the Value of Life

    Here

  • The China Convergence

    This Substack piece by N. S. Lyons is very long but very good. I invite my top commenters — I won't name names lest I inadvertently omit someone — to weigh  in on it or parts of it. The drift of the piece is announced early on: . . .when it comes to the most…

  • But isn’t math racist?

    Here Filed under: Academentia, Wokery.

  • A Question about Hell

    If hell is separation from God, why wouldn't a body held in thrall by sensuous pleasure do as well as a body wracked with pain?  Absorbed in sensuous pleasure, one is arguably farther from God than when in pain.

  • Five Grades of Agnosticism

    Substack latest. More on David Horowitz.

  • Our Knowledge of Existence: How Do I Know that a Thing Exists?

    The following incomplete draft has been languishing on my hard drive, on a memory stick, and in 'the cloud' since late November 202o.  So I will post it now to see what comments Elliot C. (and anyone else) has to offer. In other threads he has shown a burning interest in this question. ……………………….. 1)…

  • Has Satan Taken Up Residence in the Vatican?

    Reach for a supernatural explanation only after having exhausted naturalistic ones. That's a maxim of mine.  But there are so many outrages being perpetrated these days by so many people who ought to know better, people in high places, that I am sorely tempted to suspect something diabolical at work. And I am not the…

  • New Year’s Eve at the Oldies: ‘Last’ Songs for the Last Night of the Year

    Happy New Year, everybody. But as our great republic comes to an end, Irving Berlin's "The Song is Ended" seems an appropriate way to kick things off convey the thought that happiness in the coming year is more likely to be found by an inner path.  "Take your happiness while you may." Here's a hipster…

  • Saturday Night at the Oldies: Varia

    A mixed bag for your enjoyment, but mainly mine.  I post what I like and I like what I post. And I post what I've posted before. Links go bad, and even when they don't I never get tired of the old tunes I like. It's Saturday night, friends, pour yourself a stiff one and…

  • Augustine and the Epistemic Theory of Miracles

    This is a revised version of an entry from November 2009. Long-time reader Thomas Beale has got me thinking about miracles again. I cannot tell you what to believe about this vexing topic, but I can help you think clearly about it by making some distinctions.  Below I distinguish between ontic and epistemic approaches to…

  • Existence Simpliciter: Continuing the Discussion with David Brightly

     One of the points I made earlier was that presentism as a non-tautological, substantive thesis in the philosophy of time cannot be formulated without the notion of existence simpliciter. I then asked David Brightly whether he accepted the notion. Here is his reply: Do I accept the notion of existence simpliciter? Yes and No. In so…

  • Saturday Night at the Oldies: Varia

    I post what I like, and I like what I post. It's a nostalgia trip, and a generational thing. There's no point in disputing taste or sensibility, or much of anything else. It's Saturday night, punch the clock, pour yourself a stiff one, stop thinking, and FEEL! Traveling Wilburys, End of Line, Extended Version "The…

  • COMPACT Mag (Not a gun post!)

    This new online journal looks really good.  From the 'About' page: Our editorial choices are shaped by our desire for a strong social-democratic state that defends community—local and national, familial and religious—against a libertine left and a libertarian right. I too oppose libertinism and libertarianism.  I note in passing that they in some respects feed…