Footnotes to Plato from the foothills of the Superstition Mountains

Category: Personalism

  • Souls and Murder

     A guest post by Peter Lupu.  Comments in blue by BV. If there are immortal souls, would murder be a grave moral breach? 1) Theists, like their atheist adversaries, consider murder a severe breach of morality. Unlike causing a minor physical injury to another or damaging or even completely destroying their home, car, or other belongings,…

  • Why We Should Accept the Potentiality Principle

    The idea behind the Potentiality Principle (PP) is that potential personhood confers a right to life. For present purposes we may define a person as anything that is sentient, rational, and self-aware. Actual persons have a right to life, a right not to be killed. Presumably we all accept the following Rights Principle: RP: All…

  • Persons and the Moral Relevance of Their Capacities

    Those who accept the following Rights Principle (RP) presumably also accept as a codicil thereto a Capacities Principle (CP): RP. All persons have a right to life. CP. All persons have a right to life even at times when they are not exercising any of the capacities whose exercise confers upon them the right to…